I’ve found myself this week thinking a lot about one topic. Two actually. Now I’m finding myself trying to tie these together. One of which… Has perhaps been bothering me without any real concrete understanding of what it was since 1st Grade. It’s no surprise, that I of any individual, get involved into the inner workings of schools the way I do.
Another Brick In The Wall, Pt. 2 is regarded as one of the greater songs of Pink Floyd.
A satire on the workings of schools. Describing the teachers and the ultimate destiny of the people, the purpose, of the schools as an unneeded wall in the way. Perhaps this is true, perhaps this is not. Certainly, I see some hint that some of the other thinkers in the edublosphere can have some sort of sentiment with this all around. Often referencing “The Wall” in some way whether it be for marketing or in the form of some other analogy…
Like the Titanic. I quote from the book, Why Schools Fail. The passage I am taking, is after the Author… Bruce Goldberg describe the president of Harvard’s study of the High School Public School System, declaring it a success. That was in 1959. Before this passage, it brings up the fact that a third of new teachers at the time quit the profession, and there was a 25% dropout rate. As well as mentioning the issue of the psychoactive drugs to make students… “Manageable. “
“… Facts like those have led some observers to conclude that if the system can be said to be working, it is doing so very poorly. Within 10 years of Conant’s [Comment: 1969.... The year Herbert Kohl, another author I find profound in his works in education wrote the book "The Open Classroom"] optimistic study of high schools, there were calls for a complete restructuring, or even abandonment, of formal education, and the bestseller list featured such titles as “Crisis in the Classroom,” “The Underachieving School,” and “Deschooling Society. ” The central question raised by those and other works was, Why is the system not working anything like it was intended?”
The way it was intended to work was decided in the 1840’s during the Transcendentalism period in United States History. By Horace Mann, whom has and will be continued (in most regards to the ’system’; which of course makes such decisions) to be revered as the father of Education. If perhaps, only for establishing the mandated attendance form of the public school system that many states adopted. As well as lobbying for a nation wide adaptation in the legislature.
Bruce Goldberg puts a satire on this figure, for whom of which, if he never existed and did what he did… None of us here in the edublosphere could rightly say for certain, that we would indeed be here where we are today. (The book was published in 1996… The latest I have next to Adam Fletcher’s Meaningful Student Involvement.)
The system is not working the way we intended it to work for a numerous reasons. The larges of which is, the way a school, or the system itself should, should is relative. We all have different vying views and perspectives of the roles of school in our society. All of which are chaotically based upon one’s own view of how an ideal society should be implemented. In other words, there’s no unity, so consistent results should never be expected.
That, and we’ve lost track of the meaning of a school. We’ve degraded the “students” person over time and treat them as if they were lesser beings. They feel this way. They’re stricken by the narrow mindedness, the tunnel vision, that we have of how society should be rather the promotion of autism. Which, like the word school itself, has been in it’s vernacular form stricken of it’s true meaning. Belief in oneself, working for ones own needs and desires.
Rather, such a concept of autism is regarded as a disease of the mind. That’s where we pushed it since some psychologist decided that children displaying less interest in others and more so on themselves were lesser intelligent forms of life and called them outcasts that needed special attention and thus segregated for being instead of celebrated for diversity. Which only, concentrates beyond a comprehendable point the segregation schools have amounted to over the last 160 years, starting first from Age… Then to Elitism, Racism, and now various forms of Beliefism. (Hey look, I’m Shakespeare. I made a word up. Now I’m either going be shot for not using ‘proper English’ or revered as a saint in the literary arts. Get your coins for flipping and bets ready folks. )
School, the word, originally meant “leisurely learning. ” Now it describes an institution of the enforcement of pushing ideals, thoughts, fact, beliefs, skills, definitives, and a medley of a bunch of other possible understanding and comprehensions at varying and sometimes contradictory craftsmanship levels. How, could in the world, could such an institution, change so drastically in meaning? Don’t point out to me that it had 1,600+ years, roughly, to do so. I am quite aware.
I challenge that the Titanic ever hit an iceberg.
(the analogy, that is) I’d say it comes more from the people abandoning a ship that hasn’t yet made it to a cold, Artic Ocean. A ship with no passengers is just as bad as a ship that’s sinking in the case of which the analogy is used. I see lots of support for Distance Education… I would say, for the sake of diversity in the understanding of multi-media based communications it would be good for the “students” who do not experience this daily to understand this. Coming from the border of Generation Y and Generation Z, literally depending on which classification you look at… I have a mixed perspective, or you would assume. It’s these generational gaps, and stereotypes, that cause the largest problems. While it may be well done to use these for the purpose of understanding, don’t use it to flaunt the individual value and mindset of any sentient being.
It’s time to change how we acknowledge the roles of schools in our great nation, and perhaps around the world. It’s time to stop trying to break the wall down, undermine it by looking for it’s holes or walk around it… It’s time we scale the wall. If we, or anyone else hopes to advance as a person this is the best choice. This is by far, a bigger challenge than shattering people or ignoring their state as a human being. I refer to the staff of a school.
Though at the same time, the wall needs to be built strong enough to support your weight. The weaker teachers… Need to be not trodden on, rather made stronger and reinforced. Either that or when your weight crushes the brick under you, be prepared to fall. A student who comes out with nothing from the school system, has no one to blame but themselves. They will be met with challenges, some harder than others.
However, even if it is made so the system sees you as a failure and you decide to accept such a label, then you’ve no one to blame than yourself. You’re the one who has accepted that status, society may frown upon the fact that you’ve been labeled by the schools as such in quality… But that certainly will not, and should not prevent you from prevailing and meeting your dreams. Bill Gates never finished Harvard afterall. Some of the greatest thinkers were either out of place in the system, or didn’t ever attend ‘formal’ school.
I take this twist to strike one clear point: We learn best when we’re challenged. Failure is the easy way out. To go by the system, to cheat the system, to undermine and challenge the system is to make the wall that much higher. You don’t escape society, no matter how hippie like you may try to become. Society is still there. Watching. Perhaps mocking you from afar in your little commune. Perhaps pitying you…. At a loss of words. It’s all relative.
The school system, publicly, shall and needs to remain intact. The tying glue presently between young people and older people. The only thing that needs to change, is our understanding of these social reactors. I see many teachers, with inflammatory policies. Perhaps not understanding the significant role they have for about 120+ young people per day. More so in the High School setting.
Where… If lucky, you’ll spend perhaps an hour per day in the presence of these adults who determine and shape your future. Due to their role in deciding your destiny, it may be troublesome that the only relationship you may hold lesser than with most of them, is the equivalent to the relationship you hold with someone you’ve yet to meet.
The school is a social system. I’ve seen many challenges to the system regarding it as a business… If it is a business, then it’s poorly derived one that sells nothing and serves dissatisfaction. Others much like Mr. Drake(warning: This post involves a heated argument involving Arthus Erea.) bring up the point of school being Politics. However, if it were I’m sorry but the “Democrative Dictorialship” will end soon enough. How it ends, depends on the people, the students, and their dissatisfaction rating and how they choose to take care of the problem. Whether it be through the ideal of violent revolution such as those idealized by Mao ZeDung, or a progressive civil disobedience much like the kind Henry David Thoreau suggests.
School is the definitive tying rope of our society. It’s where the young people come and grow up, spending 6+ hours typically per day in the hallowed halls of the school building. Perhaps it’s time we learn the inner workings of society… Politics, Idealism, Religion, Technology, Economy(Business)… We use something called PIRATES at Capital for analyzing historicle events, facts, time periods, ect. The S is Social. I spelled PIRATE for you already. Perhaps it’s time to recognize that Social is the definitive of Society. The aspects in PIRATE defines Society, social is almost worthless. Other than you can tag what is excluded from PIRATE into Society. By using the S.
You’re probably thinking by now I’m schizophrenic. With no tunnel vision laser guided pin pointed topic. That’s because the concept of Society is broad. This is the ultimate challenge to Rome… And perhaps the Rubicon. It’s time we recognize who we are here in my nation, and perhaps the the rest of the nations of the collective world as well.
It is this, the tunnel mindedness, combined with the efforts or ideals to cross the Rubicon as much as the Republic fails to adequately meet the needs of the people for whom it serves that will prevent Rome from being built as a long standing feasible solution. We are to ununited, to narrow minded, and too ignorant as we stand here today to accomplish such a task of Rome. Everyone who reads this, will not be a part of the party that truly, truly should be reading this. It is the people whom do not listen, do not care, cannot find this, or look out for some other party person or reason rather than the overall well being of all stake holders… That hold the power to make Rome a possibility.
Drake brought this up as well in his post to Students2.0 almost immediately after the launch date. (He also mentioned not to ignore some of the big problems, many named here. Some suggested by Diane, but then Sylvia suggested to stay away… So we’re at a fundamental loss in ideals. However, quieting things is a bad thing, as seen in previous blog entries of mine and then it’s just a big circle of double standards. ) Now, I have a challenge to you if you’ve managed to read this far. Spread the word, but not to your best friend who agrees with you on everything just about. Show your school administrators. Show some contact in the local news. Show a politician. Show a lobbyist. Show the parents… Show the people what is out their. Open their minds, rather than sit where you are and discuss the possibilities. Take the extra effort to spin the cog that pushed the machine to go.
Let’s involve everyone in solving something we all seem to find a problem, or some need of some sort of improvement. Collectively, and only through collaboration, may an answer arrive. Without communicating, how do we hope, to make such a drastic change in Social Order? The simple answer, is by sitting here we cannot. I have not blogged, adequately, since before my Winter Break. A lot of my plans, my goals, are in the process of being completed. Several projects, a lot of time. I don’t have time for blogging unless I force it into my schedule. However, I see some people daily blogging. About what can be done. Will Richardson, while I don’t actively read his blog. Often brings up the point of how people should get up and just get to the doing, and use the blog to provide primary sources upon what they have done, rather than what they will do.
I see many people bring this point forward. Few follow this philosophy, perhaps it time… We do so. The blogs, the conversations, it’s a good thing. However, there comes a time to step up, or step out. That is why I make the challenge I have today, because I’m curious how many people will read this and take it and run with it. For a lot of our goals, require business skills and political reasoning. Which is no surprise since we do deal in society, so we can’t isolate one or the other. We have to look past short term profit, and we have to look past the by-partisan system. It’s time to take things to a personal level, decide what is truly the best to bring about the best change in our society.
With problems ranging from Ageism, Adultism, Racism, Climate Change, Bullying the list goes on. School is an institution where many of the beliefs and values of the previous generation are passed to be repeated seemingly indefinitely. We need to look at what those are, and ask ourselves, are we truly accomplishing progress? As it stands now… I don’t think so. Even something as seemingly beneficial as using the clause of the seperation of Church and State on schools is, due to the lack of understanding and recognition of peoples religious beliefs it often causes and increased form in such discrimination and seemed to twist the trend around from what the social norm was 200 years ago.
It seems we’ll gladly trade one form of discrimination for another, or promote an ignorance for the sake of hiding past mistakes and misunderstandings to try and prevent discriminative values. However, we’ve not once managed to prevent that, and perhaps never will. However, the time has come we need to try a different process. Status quo does not cut it anymore.
I talk to my friends, acquaintances at school and it’s a shame to hear how they’ve come to accept many of these problems as what is normal, right, and how things should be. Which is sad looking to the state of business, as it’s one counter to why our school system set up the way it is. That’s the explanation for the hierarchy I’ve presented in the past, is it’s a reflection of our business. Yet, in another country across the sea, they’ve flattened that hierarchy… And have become a world competitor economically. That country Japan… Even out of the ruins of World War II.
People asked me for what I view for Rome, and as it stands I believe the duty of a teacher, not the job requirement, but the duty of a teacher or another staff member at school is to enrich the students ability to learn and comprehend on multiple intelligence levels and help them find themselves as well as their idea of success. More often than not, we throw our values and ideals at people to try and force persuade them to coincide with ours. People look to what power they have, rather than what they can do. Sounds contradictory, but in nature they are to separate things.
What I can do, is I can be different. And I am. The long haired freaky person who is only such for that sake. I haven’t, really, formally introduced myself, who I am, what I do, I’ve just come and mentioned a few noteworthy events in my life on this blog. My name is Dillon Decicio. To put who I am in the most rudimentary form possible, I am myself. Who that is, definitively, is relative and I’ve no intention to try and force persuade that to anyone. I know who I am to myself, and that’s all I need.
The Tu Ha’ Buts Learning Center Project I have going has more goals set than just being some 17 year old teaching a course. I’ve already taught at age 16, but with more limited powers.. And technically, I’ve taught sooner to anyone who’s learned anything from me. Intentional, or not. Active Learning requires no definitive teachers or students.
With the project going, I’m making my own curriculum, and taking a different approach and going to go so far as to propose it in the form it is to the system as it stands. It’s a non traditional form of approach. The classes haven’t started yet, largely because the chaos of which is our society. It’s good, it hasn’t started yet. There have been… Too many complications of authoritative forces, that have stricken me to a point where my time is vastly limited and I can only manage so much. At the end of this week, that will change.
At the end of this week, there will be a class that’s set to start the following week. I never mentioned the nature of this project at the beginning, and if it goes through as planned there will be a comparative to my form of teaching to the standard I’ve seen and been through already up to this point. If it seems beneficial and successful, the findings will be presented to my tribal council for a request of support of expansion.
As I’ve said in the past, I hesitate greatly to release the details of this project publically. For if I did, I may make mistake by doing so. For the unfortunate problem of accredation. I’m not entirely sure who has the Intellectual Property Rights for the work I’m doing, since I am being paid to accomplish this task. It may very well be Tu Ha’ Buts. Either way, I’d prefer to keep it a more reserved level to colleagues or people who have similar experience in the field of technologies that I plan on covering.
I release this all to you, because I question my role in this society. I question Students2.0’s role in society. Comparative to what the preceding “Student” would be, and the idea of advancement from the Web to Web3.0… I see a static, “To be seen but not heard,” Evolution to, “Yell about what you think if you are a youth, and converse with those older than you if you so choose. ” Despite… The idea is in Students2.0 you’re student. I’m a student and a teacher. Have been for a while. So continue I will. Referring back to Sean’s post about the future of Students2.0…
(I find it unfortunate this conversation has ended, however.) As well as the Student Voice quality aspect of the organization…
What deems you allowed to be a ‘contributer?’ Do you not have to be a student? What prevents you from no longer being a student once you graduate? Will we have to wait for Students3.0 to acknowledge life long learning? As I’m sure, the teacher who are above us, are still learning and students in some fashion as well. Why do we have, such segregative ideologies of age separation anyways?
That and we may consider looking beyond blogginess…. Let ‘guest posters’ in to have their two bits to what’s important and valued. Let students… Of all levels speak in the manner they’re accustomed too. Break the tunnel vision, not the wall.
Now that I’ve finished by shooting my foot, I leave you, the reader, to contemplate, and digest what I’ve just stated… All several points of it.
Brick Wall Picture by ana_lee_smith is away
Titanic Picture by mando maniac